A meeting between former U.S. President Donald Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney took an unexpected turn when Trump revived his long-standing fantasy of making Canada the 51st state. The May 6 discussion at the White House quickly shifted from diplomatic pleasantries to a blunt exchange over national sovereignty.
Trump, ever the provocateur, opened with his usual flair, suggesting that “everybody” would support merging the two countries. He painted the idea as a “wonderful marriage,” but Carney wasted no time in dismissing it. Despite acknowledging Trump’s influence as a “transformational president,” the Canadian leader stood firm. “Canada is not for sale,” he declared. “It won’t be for sale, ever.”
Carney’s refusal was more than just political posturing—it was a statement of national identity. He emphasized that certain values, like sovereignty and self-determination, cannot be bought or negotiated. Referencing Canada’s historical autonomy, he subtly reminded Trump that the country has always been “masters in our own home,” answerable to no outside authority.
Trump, never one to back down easily, countered with his trademark optimism. Quoting Justin Bieber’s hit song, he smirked, “Never say never,” and alluded to his history of pulling off improbable deals. But Carney’s resolve was unshakable, leaving little room for further debate.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney claps back hard at Trump’s idea about Canada becoming the 51st state.
Trump: "As a real estate developer, when you get rid of that artificial line, when you look at that beautiful formation together, I said, ‘that’s the way it was meant to… pic.twitter.com/oPqBuhLACc
— Ed Krassenstein (@EdKrassen) May 6, 2025
Observers noted the underlying tension in their interactions. Body language expert Beth Dawson pointed out that while Carney appeared composed, subtle cues—like a restrained handshake—betrayed his discomfort. The exchange highlighted the stark contrast between Trump’s grandiose vision and Carney’s pragmatic defense of Canadian independence.
The episode served as yet another reminder of Trump’s fondness for controversial, headline-grabbing ideas. But for Canadians, the message was clear: no matter who sits in the White House, their country’s sovereignty remains intact.
