Donald Trump has a new idea for dealing with America’s most dangerous criminals—send them to Alcatraz. The former president recently floated the idea of reopening the infamous island prison, arguing that the country needs a tougher approach to crime.
The proposal has ignited controversy. Supporters say it would send a strong message to violent offenders, while critics argue it’s a step backward for criminal justice. Alcatraz, which closed in 1963, is now a popular historical site, attracting visitors fascinated by its grim past. Trump’s plan would require turning it back into a functioning prison, complete with modern security upgrades.
Legal and logistical challenges stand in the way. The National Park Service currently manages the island, and any changes would need congressional approval. Financial costs would also be steep, raising questions about whether the plan is realistic.
Opponents, including Democratic lawmakers, accuse Trump of using the idea to rally his base rather than offering practical solutions. Meanwhile, historians and preservationists worry about losing an important piece of America’s past.
As the discussion unfolds, Trump’s Alcatraz proposal highlights the ongoing clash between tough-on-crime politics and calls for more progressive justice reforms.
